登陆注册
5583100000027

第27章 SYSTEMS OF MYTHOLOGY(9)

This system chiefly rests on comparison between the Sanskrit names in the Rig-Veda and the mythic names in Greek, German, Slavonic, and other Aryan legends. The attempt is made to prove that, in the common speech of the undivided Aryan race, many words for splendid or glowing natural phenomena existed, and that natural processes were described in a figurative style. As the various Aryan families separated, the sense of the old words and names became dim, the nomina developed into numina, the names into gods, the descriptions of elemental processes into myths. As this system has already been criticised by us elsewhere with minute attention, a reference to these reviews must suffice in this place. Briefly, it may be stated that the various masters of the school--Kuhn, Max Muller, Roth, Schwartz, and the rest--rarely agree where agreement is essential, that is, in the philological foundations of their building. They differ in very many of the etymological analyses of mythical names. They also differ in the interpretations they put on the names, Kuhn almost invariably seeing fire, storm, cloud, or lightning where Mr. Max Muller sees the chaste Dawn. Thus Mannhardt, after having been a disciple, is obliged to say that comparative Indo-Germanic mythology has not borne the fruit expected, and that "the CERTAIN gains of the system reduce themselves to the scantiest list of parallels, such as Dyaus = Zeus = Tius, Parjanya = Perkunas, Bhaga = Bog, Varuna = Uranos" (a position much disputed), etc. Mannhardt adds his belief that a number of other "equations"--such as Sarameya = Hermeias, Saranyus = Demeter Erinnys, Kentauros = Gandharva, and many others--will not stand criticism, and he fears that these ingenious guesses will prove mere jeux d'esprit rather than actual facts. Many examples of the precarious and contradictory character of the results of philological mythology, many instances of "dubious etymologies," false logic, leaps at foregone conclusions, and attempts to make what is peculiarly Indian in thought into matter of universal application, will meet us in the chapters on Indian and Greek divine legends. "The method in its practical working shows a fundamental lack of the historical sense," says Mannhardt.

Examples are torn from their contexts, he observes; historical evolution is neglected; passages of the Veda, themselves totally obscure, are dragged forward to account for obscure Greek mythical phenomena. Such are the accusations brought by the regretted Mannhardt against the school to which he originally belonged, and which was popular and all-powerful even in the maturity of his own more clear-sighted genius. Proofs of the correctness of his criticism will be offered abundantly in the course of this work.

It will become evident that, great as are the acquisitions of Philology, her least certain discoveries have been too hastily applied in alien "matter," that is, in the region of myth. Not that philology is wholly without place or part in the investigation of myth, when there is agreement among philologists as to the meaning of a divine name. In that case a certain amount of light is thrown on the legend of the bearer of the name, and on its origin and first home, Aryan, Greek, Semitic, or the like. But how rare is agreement among philologists!

Baum und Feld Kultus, p. xvii. Kuhn's "epoch-making" book is Die Herabkunft des Feuers, Berlin, 1859. By way of example of the disputes as to the original meaning of a name like Prometheus, compare Memoires de la Societe de Linguistique de Paris, t. iv. p.

336.

See especially Mannhardt's note on Kuhn's theories of Poseidon and Hermes, B. u. F. K., pp. xviii., xix., note 1.

"The philological method," says Professor Tiele, "is inadequate and misleading, when it is a question of discovering the ORIGIN of a myth, or the physical explanation of the oldest myths, or of accounting for the rude and obscene element in the divine legends of civilised races. But these are not the only problems of mythology. There is, for example, the question of the GENEALOGICALrelations of myths, where we have to determine whether the myths of peoples whose speech is of the same family are special modifications of a mythology once common to the race whence these peoples have sprung. The philological method alone can answer here." But this will seem a very limited province when we find that almost all races, however remote and unconnected in speech, have practically much the same myths.

Rev. de l'Hist. des Rel., xii. 3, 260, Nov., Dec., 1885.

同类推荐
  • 闲燕常谈

    闲燕常谈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 黄帝阴符经解义

    黄帝阴符经解义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 温莎的风流娘儿们

    温莎的风流娘儿们

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金阙帝君三元真一经

    金阙帝君三元真一经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 奇门遁甲元灵经

    奇门遁甲元灵经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 慕卿归

    慕卿归

    相恋前……冰冷的剑刃抵在了邝慕卿的脖子上,邝慕卿一个激灵缓缓地转过了身来,苦苦哀求着:“夫君,别杀我,再给我一点时间,我一定可以撬开。”相恋后……插肩而过时,苏酒释忽然听见了玉钗在回阑轻叩,苏酒释委屈巴巴的抓住了她的衣襟,喃喃道:“你别走……”(作品尚未完结)
  • 英雄要从娃娃抓起

    英雄要从娃娃抓起

    这是一个死肥宅穿越异界,被一群小屁孩坑出血的故事!嫌弃你的队友坑?那是你没见识过真正的儿童劫,小学僧和托儿索,在江不莱的孤儿院里,联盟的英雄都还没长大呢~~
  • 游戏修补匠

    游戏修补匠

    别人都是做热门新游戏发大财,但是他却被系统坑的只能负债接手日薄西山的旧游戏对其进行改造。
  • 不宠你,宠谁

    不宠你,宠谁

    她是墨家的小女儿,他是南宫家族的长子,她刚进校就威胁了他校草的地位,又做了他的同桌,他又怎么能坐视不管。于是,他联合她的哥哥,她的爸爸对她开启了团宠模式
  • 婚瘾

    婚瘾

    四年前,在他最痛苦失意的时候,她决然离去。四年后,他已功成名就成为商界名人!而她,为了养活儿子,不得不屈居在他眼皮底下讨生活!太心塞了!有木有?不过总裁大人,要表演浓情蜜意能麻烦走开一点么?纳尼?神经分裂的总裁大人不但会调戏下属,还喜欢半夜敲她家门!
  • 追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    追妻无门:女boss不好惹

    青涩蜕变,如今她是能独当一面的女boss,爱了冷泽聿七年,也同样花了七年时间去忘记他。以为是陌路,他突然向他表白,扬言要娶她,她只当他是脑子抽风,他的殷勤她也全都无视。他帮她查她父母的死因,赶走身边情敌,解释当初拒绝她的告别,和故意对她冷漠都是无奈之举。突然爆出她父母的死居然和冷家有丝毫联系,还莫名跳出个公爵未婚夫,扬言要与她履行婚约。峰回路转,破镜还能重圆吗? PS:我又开新文了,每逢假期必书荒,新文《有你的世界遇到爱》,喜欢我的文的朋友可以来看看,这是重生类现言,对这个题材感兴趣的一定要收藏起来。
  • 男人三十不能穷

    男人三十不能穷

    三十而立;然而这是个分水岭的年龄,在这个年龄阶段,是男人最好的奋斗时间,但也是最难熬的时间,毕竟到了这个时间段,和一起长大的小伙伴以及同学之间的差距就出来了,而且一般到了这个年龄,一般都成家了,有了小孩还有逐渐年迈的父母,还有待成长起来的弟弟或者妹妹……“何鑫源,男人三十不能穷!”
  • 倒枪刺

    倒枪刺

    世界上果真有吸血鬼,柯亭身上的血不管她愿不愿意早被柯珂吸入过半。不求所需的付出和被索取是孽缘,柯亭发现自己连反驳的机会都没有过。她生而为她,选择也不在她,命运也不在她......
  • 八十天环游地球

    八十天环游地球

    《八十天环游地球》讲述了一场因打赌而起的奇幻之旅:在没有飞机、只能搭火车与邮轮的情况下,英国绅士福克和他的仆人“万事达”,经历了重重艰难险阻,最终完成了八十天环游地球这一惊人壮举。惊险刺激的旅程、奇异的风土人情、主人公诚实守信的可贵品质和沉着冷静的过人智慧,让读者大开眼界。作品发表后,引起了轰动,多次再版。1874年由作者本人改编成剧本后,同样受到广泛欢迎。
  • 村民自治与农村治安纠纷

    村民自治与农村治安纠纷

    党的十六大报告中指出:“完善村民自治,健全村党组织领导的充满活力的村民自治机制。”这给我国农村村民自治的深入发展指明了方向。发端于20世纪80年代的中国农村村民自治,是中国共产党领导下的亿万农民的伟大创举,是中国现代史上第一次农村基层社会真正的、全面的直接民主实践,有力地推进了农村物质文明、精神文明和政治文明建设的发展,并取得了较大的成就。