登陆注册
5656400000019

第19章

Well then, I said, let me suppose that they repeat their question, What account do you give of that which, in our way of speaking, is termed being overcome by pleasure? I should answer thus: Listen, and Protagoras and I will endeavour to show you. When men are overcome by eating and drinking and other sensual desires which are pleasant, and they, knowing them to be evil, nevertheless indulge in them, would you not say that they were overcome by pleasure? They will not deny this. And suppose that you and I were to go on and ask them again: "In what way do you say that they are evil-in that they are pleasant and give pleasure at the moment, or because they cause disease and poverty and other like evils in the future? Would they still be evil, if they had no attendant evil consequences, simply because they give the consciousness of pleasure of whatever nature?"-Would they not answer that they are not evil on account of the pleasure which is immediately given by them, but on account of the after consequences-diseases and the like?

I believe, said Protagoras, that the world in general would answer as you do.

And in causing diseases do they not cause pain? and in causing poverty do they not cause pain;-they would agree to that also, if I am not mistaken?

Protagoras assented.

Then I should say to them, in my name and yours: Do you think them evil for any other reason, except because they end in pain and rob us of other pleasures:-there again they would agree?

We both of us thought that they would.

And then I should take the question from the opposite point of view, and say: "Friends, when you speak of goods being painful, do you not mean remedial goods, such as gymnastic exercises, and military service, and the physician's use of burning, cutting, drugging, and starving? Are these the things which are good but painful?"-they would assent to me?

He agreed.

"And do you call them good because they occasion the greatest immediate suffering and pain; or because, afterwards, they bring health and improvement of the bodily condition and the salvation of states and power over others and wealth?"-they would agree to the latter alternative, if I am not mistaken?

He assented.

"Are these things good for any other reason except that they end in pleasure, and get rid of and avert pain? Are you looking to any other standard but pleasure and pain when you call them good?"-they would acknowledge that they were not?

I think so, said Protagoras.

"And do you not pursue after pleasure as a good, and avoid pain as an evil?"He assented.

"Then you think that pain is an evil and pleasure is a good: and even pleasure you deem an evil, when it robs you of greater pleasures than it gives, or causes pains greater than the pleasure.

If, however, you call pleasure an evil in relation to some other end or standard, you will be able to show us that standard. But you have none to show."I do not think that they have, said Protagoras.

"And have you not a similar way of speaking about pain? You call pain a good when it takes away greater pains than those which it has, or gives pleasures greater than the pains: then if you have some standard other than pleasure and pain to which you refer when you call actual pain a good, you can show what that is. But you cannot."True, said Protagoras.

Suppose again, I said, that the world says to me: "Why do you spend many words and speak in many ways on this subject?" Excuse me, friends, I should reply; but in the first place there is a difficulty in explaining the meaning of the expression "overcome by pleasure"; and the whole argument turns upon this. And even now, if you see any possible way in which evil can be explained as other than pain, or good as other than pleasure, you may still retract.

Are you satisfied, then, at having a life of pleasure which is without pain? If you are, and if you are unable to show any good or evil which does not end in pleasure and pain, hear the consequences:-If what you say is true, then the argument is absurd which affirms that a man often does evil knowingly, when he might abstain, because he is seduced and overpowered by pleasure; or again, when you say that a man knowingly refuses to do what is good because he is overcome at the moment by pleasure. And that this is ridiculous will be evident if only we give up the use of various names, such as pleasant and painful, and good and evil. As there are two things, let us call them by two names-first, good and evil, and then pleasant and painful.

同类推荐
  • 大乘八大曼拏罗经

    大乘八大曼拏罗经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 四分僧戒本

    四分僧戒本

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 仙卜奇缘

    仙卜奇缘

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 元曲集(下)

    元曲集(下)

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 无见先睹禅师语录

    无见先睹禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 大爱无边

    大爱无边

    周建新,男,满族,一级作家,一九六三年冬月生于辽宁兴城,出版及发表长篇小说《老滩》等8部,在《当代》、《十月》等文学期刊发表中短小说百余篇,作品多次被《小说月报》、《小说选刊》、《新华文摘》等转载,多次获得辽宁文学奖。获得过全国“骏马奖”、辽宁优秀青年作家奖。现供职于辽宁葫芦岛市文联。一个人感动几个人并不难,难的是感动成千上万的人。一个人做几点奉献并不难,难的是一辈子只做奉献,不去索取。一个人得到几许赞誉并不难,难的是众口一词的赞誉,没有杂音。
  • 野秧子

    野秧子

    金钱、美色、权力、良心、正义?同样在农村中浸泡着男人、女人的生活,奇事、嘎事、怪事、趣事也成筐成箩,所不同的是,乡间的那些事比城市的柔媚、嗲气,少了些羞赧和虚伪,更多的是率真和粗犷,甚至是野性,那“一亩三分地儿”里的故事让你想也想不到……
  • 龙池寺望月寄韦使君

    龙池寺望月寄韦使君

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 洪荒之缘来是猴

    洪荒之缘来是猴

    确定的是假系统,确定的是假主角。砰砰砰,画重点圈起来,反正也不考。修仙体会其中意味深长……
  • 诸天万界神龙进化系统

    诸天万界神龙进化系统

    新书《会穿越的面包车》起航,有兴趣的可以移驾,收藏一下,推荐票给新书,拜谢!还有两百万字完本老书《畅游诸天影视世界》宅男林青,重生为蛇,在在诸天万界之中进化,不仅是为了强大,也是为了找到回家的路。PS:本书后期化龙之后就会化形,不喜勿喷。以穿越世界《狂蟒之灾2》《僵尸先生》《生化危机》《环太平洋》;《倩女幽魂》《海贼王黄泉乡大冒险》《诛仙》《狐妖小红娘》;《蜀山传》《斗罗大陆》《妇联4》《哪吒之魔童降世》《无限恐怖》《斗破苍穹》后续待定...群:521040565
  • 圣石的诅咒

    圣石的诅咒

    神秘的圣石是带来幸运,还是带来受诅咒,善恶生于人心之中,命运掌握在自己的手中。
  • 安安静静就好了

    安安静静就好了

    (1v1)纯情学霸:“我想要的,很简单,时光还在你还在。”
  • 居里夫人自传:不虚度的一生

    居里夫人自传:不虚度的一生

    我们应该不虚度一生,应该能够说:“我已经做了我能做的事。”爱因斯坦最为推崇的女科学家,两次获得诺贝尔奖的第一人。北京国际关系学院教授、著名翻译家陈筱卿译作,经典作品权威呈现。居里夫人用一生诠释:把人生变成科学的梦,把梦变成现实。比成功更可贵的,是一个纯洁而高尚的灵魂。本书分两部分:第一部分语言直白、坦诚,是一个普通女孩通过自己的刻苦努力,顽强奋斗走上科学之路的真实写照;第二部分是由居里夫人撰写的丈夫皮埃尔·居里的传记,通过居里夫人的记叙、两人的书信和日记、他人的评价等多个角度展现了皮埃尔·居里的高尚人格魅力。
  • 找人办事有方法

    找人办事有方法

    人的谋求生存与发展,所要依靠的有两种能力,一种是专业技术能力,一种是在社会上的办事能力。提高办事能力就能提高生存质量,办事能力是一个人综合素质的集中体现。本书讲述了该如何去编织自己广阔的人脉,如何处理各种复杂的社会关系,如何与人交往,从而使自己可以在复杂的人际关系中办好每一件事。
  • 快穿炮灰很硬核

    快穿炮灰很硬核

    南音作为游荡在人间十多年的魂体,一日被系统选定,带着伟大任务,踏入万千小世界。奈何出师不利,第一个世界就被任务目标弄死了两次,好不容易从系统那里获得了支援道具,可是这些异能都是什么鬼?需要亲密接触才能使用的读心术,总是失灵到反派面前的瞬移术……南音觉得她才是需要被拯救的那个。